neighborhood selector neighborhood selector
minimum price
Min
Max
maximum price
Search
More Filters
Reset

Sheepshead Bay Apartments for Rent - New York, NY

Sort: Quality Price
38 Results
Prev  1 2 3  Next
720 Ave Y
Sheepshead Bay, Southern Brooklyn, Brooklyn
11235
$5,000
Exclusive
By Manager, 6 hours ago
bedrooms
3 Bed
|
bathrooms
2 Bath
|
square feet
1,500 Sqft
Check Availability
1713 E 14th, Apt I
Homecrest, Sheepshead Bay, Southern Brooklyn, Brooklyn
11229
$2,500
Exclusive
By Manager, 13 hours ago
bedrooms
1 Bed
|
bathrooms
1 Bath
|
square feet
800 Sqft
Check Availability
2128 Ocean Ave, Apt 7B
Homecrest, Sheepshead Bay, Southern Brooklyn, Brooklyn
11229
$3,000
Exclusive
By Kerry Sullivan, 1 day ago
bedrooms
1 Bed
|
bathrooms
1 Bath
|
square feet
657 Sqft
Check Availability
2626 Homecrest Avenue, Apt 2U
Sheepshead Bay, Southern Brooklyn, Brooklyn
11235
$2,000
Exclusive
By Dayhana Jerez, 18 hours ago
bedrooms
1 Bed
|
bathrooms
1 Bath
Check Availability
1200 Gravesend Neck Road, Apt ...
Homecrest, Sheepshead Bay, Southern Brooklyn, Brooklyn
11229
$2,850
Exclusive
By Daniel Abramov , 6 hours ago
bedrooms
2 Bed
|
bathrooms
2 Bath
|
square feet
1,200 Sqft
Check Availability
Avenue V
Sheepshead Bay, Southern Brooklyn, Brooklyn
11229
$3,700
By Avishag Iluz, 13 hours ago
bedrooms
2 Bed
|
bathrooms
2 Bath
Check Availability
Bedford Ave
Madison, Sheepshead Bay, Southern Brooklyn, Brooklyn
11229
$2,650
By Mark Banushi, 16 hours ago
bedrooms
2 Bed
|
bathrooms
1 Bath
Check Availability
Jerome Avenue
Sheepshead Bay, Southern Brooklyn, Brooklyn
11235
$3,199
By Ainat Benattar, 15 hours ago
bedrooms
1 Bed
|
bathrooms
1 Bath
|
square feet
600 Sqft
Check Availability
Avenue Y and East 23rd Street
Sheepshead Bay, Southern Brooklyn, Brooklyn
11235
$2,695
By Daniel Abramov , 7 hours ago
bedrooms
2 Bed
|
bathrooms
1 Bath
Check Availability
2620 Hubbard St, Apt 1
Sheepshead Bay, Southern Brooklyn, Brooklyn
11235
$3,000
Exclusive
By Irine Blyumin, 16 hours ago
bedrooms
2 Bed
|
bathrooms
1 Bath
Check Availability
Kings Highway
Madison, Sheepshead Bay, Southern Brooklyn, Brooklyn
11229
$4,000
By Joseph Anteby , 1 day ago
bedrooms
Studio
|
bathrooms
0.5 Bath
Check Availability
2733 East 12th Street, Apt 3F
Sheepshead Bay, Southern Brooklyn, Brooklyn
11235
$4,050
Exclusive
No Fee
By Jonny Borochov, 4 days ago
bedrooms
2 Bed
|
bathrooms
2 Bath
Check Availability
2733 East 12th Street, Apt 3C
Sheepshead Bay, Southern Brooklyn, Brooklyn
11235
$2,995
Exclusive
No Fee
By Jonny Borochov, 4 days ago
bedrooms
1 Bed
|
bathrooms
1 Bath
Check Availability
2733 East 12th Street, Apt 3A
Sheepshead Bay, Southern Brooklyn, Brooklyn
11235
$2,625
Exclusive
No Fee
By Jonny Borochov, 4 days ago
bedrooms
1 Bed
|
bathrooms
1 Bath
Check Availability
1941 Coney Island Avenue, Apt ...
Sheepshead Bay, Southern Brooklyn, Brooklyn
11223
$2,950
Exclusive
No Fee
By , 6 days ago
bedrooms
1 Bed
|
bathrooms
1 Bath
|
square feet
661 Sqft
Check Availability
Prev  1 2 3  Next
map placeholder

Sheepshead Bay

Located right above Brighten Beach and Coney Island, Sheepshead Bay is about as suburban as it gets in Brooklyn. With a peaceful vibe and plenty of space to spread out, this neighborhood is popular with larger families and long time NYC residents looking to settle down.

Sheepshead Bay Apartments

Sheepshead Bay Apartments for Rent

Fun Facts and History of Sheepshead Bay

Sheepshead Bay was largely undeveloped for most of the colonial period and even for a point after the American Revolution. However, as the population of the Town of Gravesend expanded, development started in the early 1800’s and Sheepshead Bay was born. By the 1840’s, the area was a popular spot for NYC residents to own a summer home.

The name “Sheepshead” comes from the type of fish that could be found in the bay, which helped make the area a fishing and resort destination. Much of the area became attractive as a permanent residence for people, so single family homes and apartment complexes were constructed to keep up with demand. Soon, horse racing tracks were set up, making Sheepshead Bay a popular gambling destination as well.

New York outlawed horse betting in 1910, forcing the closure of the tracks that made much of the neighborhood popular with tourists. Construction of Coney Island amusement parks only hastened the decline of tourism in the area, making housing prices affordable. This attracted immigrants and refugees fleeing Europe during World War II and cemented the neighborhood’s residential status. Today, Sheepshead Bay isn’t much of a tourist spot, but the locals there have created a life that they can enjoy without having to travel into the busier parts of the city.

Sheepshead Bay Buildings

Several luxury high rises can be found in Sheepshead Bay, especially closer to Coney Island and the water. However, the more inland you go, the more suburban it gets. Many of the single family homes are unattached and two stories. There are several row houses as well, leaving the neighborhood mostly flat.

Atmosphere of Sheepshead Bay

Near the water and Coney Island, Sheepshead Bay can have a bit of a party vibe. It’s not as big as other parts of the city, but this area is popular with people visiting the parks and beaches. It’s not exactly raucous, but it’s not the most calm part of the neighborhood.

The more landlocked parts of the neighborhood are extremely residential. There are some bars and restaurants that provide a nightlife, but this area is mostly home to families. The people who live here do so because it's peaceful, affordable, and out of the way.

Family Score for Sheepshead Bay

This neighborhood is great for families as long as they are in the more landlocked portions. The waterfront areas aren’t dangerous, but they have a resort life that’s hard to ignore. Overall, though, Sheepshead Bay has access to good schools, a hospital, and a ton of space for families big and small. It’s a great area to live in.

Notable Schools in Sheepshead Bay
  • James Madison High School
  • Origins High School
  • IS 98 Bay Academy

Notable Residents of Sheepshead Bay
  • Vince Lombardi: NFL Coach
  • Terry Gross: NPR Host
  • Larry David: Comedian

Transportation Options in Sheepshead Bay

The New York City subway system provides access to sheepshead Bay via the B and Q trains.

Biking in this area is doable, but not very popular. The streets are wide and traffic is light, making for easy navigation. However, Citi Bike docking stations are few and far between and most people prefer to walk or drive.

Driving in Sheepshead is very popular. Most homes come with some parking availability and the traffic is very light until you get close to Coney Island.

Landmarks and Neighborhood Treasures of Sheepshead Bay
  • Madison Subsection
  • Venice Marina
  • Sheepshead Bay Muslim Center

Act Like a Local in Sheepshead Bay
  • One of the best movie theaters in Brooklyn, the Regal UA Sheepshead Bay IMAX and RPX has a ton of movies playing in this state of the art facility.
  • Looking for some great food? Try Opera Cafe Lounge or Pho Vietnam for some amazing bites!
  • Want a cocktail? Check out Tabu Lounge or Penthouse Lounge Bar to quench your thirst.

Read About Sheepshead Bay

Best Places for Christmas Trees in NYC

Learn More About Sheepshead Bay
For those interested, Sheepshead Bay currently has 38 residential listings advertised on the market for rent. Listings for rent in this area typically have an median of 982 square feet. From data that we've compiled, listings range from $2,606 in the lower quartile to $3,499 in the upper quartile. Generally speaking, the median rental price is around $2,973 or $3.13 / sqft. For those interested in renting a listing in Sheepshead Bay, there are currently 2 studio, 13 one-bedroom, 16 two-bedroom, 6 three-bedroom, and 1 four+ bedroom apartments available for rent.
For your convenience, we've included a more detailed breakdown of rental pricing by median bedroom sizes here:
Bedrooms Rent Rent / sqft
Studio $2,913 $3.65
1 BR $2,850 $4.46
2 BR $3,100 $2.60
3 BR $3,300 $2.38

We make sure to refresh our rental listings every hour in order to provide you with the newest and most up-to-date inventory available on the market.

Sheepshead Bay is located within Kings County, New York. This area currently has 2,606,852 residents in 938,803 households. Out of the total population, 40.12% of the residents speak another language at home instead of English. The majority of the inhabitants in this county are currently unmarried and have a median age of 35.

When looking at residents older than 25, around 25.80% have graduated from high school, 20.68% have a bachelor's degree, and 13.40% have obtained their master's degree or above. Employment rate is typically around 57.8% and the median income in this county is $50,640.

At least 70.55% of those living in this county are renting their homes. Most residents will commute to work by public transportation with an average commute time of 42 minutes.

Geographically, Kings County, New York is a part of the New York - Newark, NY - NJ - CT Urban Area. This county is currently home to 18,812,161 residents, or 6,707,347 households with a median income of $68,319. the New York - Newark, NY - NJ - CT Urban Area residents have a median age of 38 and 50.07% are currently renting their homes in the area.

Popular Searches
Quantcast