The 1 OR 1 Problem, No Fee, OP, and Net Effective Scams

Yesterday we gave a simple example of net effective price calculations. There is also a more in-depth explanation in our rental guide. In an ideal world, the net effective price is identical whether you approach a landlord directly or use a broker to help. A few landlords still use an out-dated incentive model, called “1 or 1” pricing.

Here is the problem. Landlords are hurting in a slow market, so they give concessions. They give free rent, and they are also willing to pay the broker fee, sometimes called “OP” short for Owner Pays Broker Fee. The problem arises when they will only do one, but not both. Here is a recent broker blast from Mercedes House, a luxury building in Midtown West.

 

 

Notice that for unit 1104 at 550 West 54th street, the landlord will pay BOTH the broker fee, and give one month free. However, for unit 812, a studio, the landlord will only pay the broker fee if they are not giving the free month.

It’s strange and confusing for all sides. On one hand, they welcome brokers and recognize the time saved from using a network of open listings agents. On the other hand, they are under-cutting the relation by asking renters to come directly… but only for certain units.

Even worse, some unethical brokers take advantage of the situation using a 1 OR 1 scam. They list the net effective, AND call it no fee when advertising. Only later on, do they inform the client that the no fee benefit only comes if they pay the gross price! As much as we believe landlords should eliminate 1 or 1 pricing, brokers advertising a No Fee must give the true no-fee price, otherwise it is false advertising and a clear violation of our policies.

Lee Lin
Lee Lin
Lee is a data geek from MIT who spent years at quantitative hedge funds cranking out models to explain and predict financial markets. Real estate has always been a big part of Lee's life. He grew up helping out at his parents' Jersey Shore motels, became a landlord his first year out of college, analyzed mortgages on a fixed-income trading desk, and acquired a New York real estate license. At RentHop, he combines his nerd talents and real estate knowledge to constantly tweak the secret HopScore. He currently lives near Bryant Park and his favorite restaurant was Cafe Zaiya (now known as Tomiz).

You May Also Like

Summer Decorations For Your Apartment

Summer is here to stay, which usually means a beach vacation, frozen margaritas, and chilling in a pleasantly decorated space. But, not everyone has...

10 Things to Check Before Renting an Apartment

Finding a new apartment is equally exciting as it is nerve-wracking. In places like New York City, renters only have a few weeks to...

The Hidden Waterfalls of New York City

New York City isnโ€™t just a huge, concrete jungle. Behind the bustling traffic and tall skyscrapers, are both natural and man-made hidden escapes. What...

Recent Articles