Application Process and Criteria for a Rental Application

Apartment searching can be stressful, especially in New York City. Even after spending all that time and energy searching for the perfect apartment, there is still the question of if the landlord will choose you out of all the other applicants. This brings us to the topic of the rental application process. What it is and what screening criteria are required for a rental application.

What is the Application Process?ย 

The application process is a landlordโ€™s way of screening for the most-qualified and least-risky future tenant. As a landlord, the last thing they want is for a tenant to miss payments on rent, mess up the apartment, and/or cause a disruption in the community that they would then have to deal with. By looking at your background and finances, a landlord can have a better idea of what kind of tenant youโ€™ll be and also if youโ€™ll be able to pay rent on time each month. Often, landlords may have a management company or real estate agent work on the screening process for them.

As a renter, there are a lot of different documents to prepare, forms to fill out, and fees to pay, so itโ€™s best to begin collecting necessary documents and putting aside enough money in a bank account prior to the start of your apartment search.

You May Also Like

Questions on an Apartment Application

To get you better prepared, here are some of the most common items you’ll need to provide on an application form:

  • Your annual salary/ income
  • Social security number
  • Employment history

Supporting Documents You’ll Need

You’ll also need to attach a group of supporting documents. The New York City rental application process is more involved than other states. You’ll likely need to submit most of the following items:ย 

  • Photo ID (password or driverโ€™s license)
  • Letter of employment with your job title, length of employment, and annual salary – this should be printed on a company letterhead
  • Copies of last two-three pay stubs
  • Copies of the last two tax returns
  • Letters of reference from past landlords/employers/guarantors – please include their contact information*
  • Personal letters of reference*

*These can be optional (though submitting these will provide you with a stronger application)

Application Fees and Other Costs

Along with the application form and supporting documents are application fees and deposits that the landlord may expect you to pay. Here are the three most common ones:

Application Fee

The landlord may require each person on the application to pay this fee. This fee covers the processing of the application.

Credit Check Authorization Fee

Landlords will commonly run a credit check on each person on the application. This fee covers fee that landlords will have to pay in order to run a credit check.

โ€œGood-Faith Depositโ€

Some landlords will ask applicants to submit a deposit to temporarily take the apartment you are interested off the market. You should be able to receive your deposit back if your application is denied by the landlord.

Beware: Never hand over your personal information or submit any fees to the landlord or agent until you have seen the apartment you want in person. This is the best way to protect yourself against scammers.

Important Criteria for a Landlord to Consider

So what are some important criteriaโ€™s a landlord may consider during the application process?

Credit Score

A credit score is a good representation of your financial responsibility. The better your ability to pay off your loans and pay your bills on time, the higher your credit score. A credit score is generally a number between 300 and 850. As implied, the higher your score, the better.

If your credit score is lower, your landlord may require that you pay a few months rent upfront or a larger security deposit so they can minimize the chances of you not paying rent on time. Federal law stipulates that you are allowed to get a free copy of your credit report every year from each credit reporting company. You should be checking this yearly to ensure that your information is correct and up-to-date. A great resource is http://annualcreditreport.com.

Sufficient Income

Outside of your credit score, landlords will also need to be sure that you are making sufficient income so that you can afford rent on a monthly basis. If you do not make enough to cover rent, you should consider getting a guarantor.

Stable Employment History

This kind of goes hand-in-hand with having sufficient income, but having a stable employment history, implies that there is a less likely chance that you will run out of income to pay rent.

Clean Eviction Record

Landlords will often check for your eviction record. A clean record implies that other landlords havenโ€™t had issues with you and the more you will be viewed as a good potential tenant.

Reference Letters

Outside of your finances, landlords will also view applicants with great reference letters in a favorable light. So if you can attain great reference letters from your employee, past landlord, or guarantor, that should add some extra oomph to your application!

Editor’s Note: We updated this article to enhance readability.ย 

Faye Chou
Faye Chou
Faye is the Managing Director of the RentHop Operations team. In her 10 years at RentHop, Faye has written numerous articles on a variety of real estate topics. If you're interested in learning more about the current state of the rental housing market or want Faye's best tips for your apartment search then check out more of her articles.

You May Also Like

Summer Decorations For Your Apartment

Summer is here to stay, which usually means a beach vacation, frozen margaritas, and chilling in a pleasantly decorated space. But, not everyone has...

10 Things to Check Before Renting an Apartment

Finding a new apartment is equally exciting as it is nerve-wracking. In places like New York City, renters only have a few weeks to...

The Hidden Waterfalls of New York City

New York City isnโ€™t just a huge, concrete jungle. Behind the bustling traffic and tall skyscrapers, are both natural and man-made hidden escapes. What...

Recent Articles